The Prince of Pittsburgh's Perfect Pizza Quest
The Prince of Pittsburgh has made his decision on the pizza offered by these establishments. Six attributes were evaluated on a 1-10 scale for a possible perfect score of 60.
667 Castle Creek Dr.
Seven Fields, PA 16046
724-778-9955
www.carluccissevenfields.com
February 7, 2025
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
7 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
5 - Sauce
6 - Crust
6 - Topping Amount
5 - General Flavor
35 - Total Score
The pizza was average, but the extras (wings, JoJos, etc.) were excellent
4251 Northern Pike
Monroeville, PA 15146
412-372-2977
gatewaygrill35@yahoo.com
February 28, 2025
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
6 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
6 - Sauce
4 - Crust
7 - Topping Amount
5 - General Flavor
34 - Total Score
Sometimes it just depends when the pizza gets taken out of the oven. In this case, had it been removed 90 seconds earlier, the crust , appearance, and general flavor would have received higher scores
Ohio
3975 Cascades Blvd.
Kent, OH 44240
234-233-1494
November 18, 2024
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
7 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
5 - Sauce
6 - Crust
6 - Topping Amount
5 - General Flavor
35 - Total Score
The pizza was average, but the extras (wings, JoJos, etc.) were excellent
509 Pittsburgh Street
Mars, PA 16046
724-625-1616
November 29, 2024
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
6 - Appearance
5 - Cheese
7 - Sauce
5 - Crust
9 - Topping Amount
6 - General Flavor
38 - Total Score
The pizza was average, but was still very good the next day when it was cold.
2016 Smallman St.
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
412-429-7272
www.papajs.com
January 12, 2025
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pizza tray:
7 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
8 - Sauce
7 - Crust
8 - Topping Amount
7 - General Flavor
43 - Total Score
It was very good, slightly pricey, but Papa J's is a full-blown Italian restaurant as opposed to a pizza joint. Try their zucchini!
Pine Township, PA
11085 Babcock Blvd
Gibsonia PA 15044
724-65-2600
November 11, 2024
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
8 - Appearance
5 - Cheese
8 - Sauce
5 - Crust
7 - Topping Amount
6 - General Flavor
39 - Total Score
This has been my go-to Pizza Place for years. I think they had a bad day or perhaps I've been overrating them.
2016 Smallman St.
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
412-429-7272
December 23, 2024
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
8 - Appearance
7 - Cheese
7 - Sauce
6 - Crust
8 - Topping Amount
7 - General Flavor
43 - Total Score
Very good and cheaper than most.
2016 Smallman St.
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
412-429-7272
December 23, 2024